Management letter after a grant audit: how to read it and respond to the donor
A management letter after a grant or NGO audit is a separate written document in which the auditor describes the internal control deficiencies identified, their potential effects and recommendations. The duty to communicate significant deficiencies in writing comes from ISA 265 (paragraphs 9 and 10), and the donor usually expects the organisation to respond to every finding: what has been done, who is responsible and by when.
Below we explain how a management letter differs from the audit report, how to read findings by risk level and how to write a response to the donor so that the next audit does not repeat the same points.
What is a management letter after a grant audit?
International Standard on Auditing 265, Communicating Deficiencies in Internal Control to Those Charged with Governance and Management, distinguishes two levels. A deficiency in internal control exists when a control cannot prevent, or detect and correct, misstatements on a timely basis, or when a necessary control is missing altogether. A significant deficiency is a deficiency or combination of deficiencies that, in the auditor’s professional judgment, merits the attention of those charged with governance (the board, supervisory board or foundation council).
The auditor communicates significant deficiencies to those charged with governance and to management in writing and on a timely basis (ISA 265, paragraphs 9 and 10). Other deficiencies that merit management’s attention are also communicated, but not necessarily in writing. In practice, these communications are collected in one document called the management letter. The standard was written for audits of financial statements, yet donors often ask for the same letter after a project audit and list it as a separate deliverable in the audit terms of reference. Text of the standard: iaasb.org.
How does a management letter differ from the audit report?
- Subject. The report contains the auditor’s opinion (or factual findings of procedures) on the project financial report. The management letter is about how accounting and control work: expense approval, procurement, supporting documents, bank access.
- Addressee. The report is read by the donor and often a third party. The letter is addressed to the board and management of the organisation, although the donor often receives a copy.
- Consequences. A modified opinion or ineligible expenditure in the report means financial questions right now. A finding in the management letter is first of all a task to fix, but an unfixed task becomes more serious at the next audit.
- Limits. Under paragraph 11 of ISA 265, the auditor explains that the audit was not designed to express an opinion on the effectiveness of internal control and that the letter covers only the deficiencies identified during the work. So the absence of a finding does not mean that controls in that area are flawless.
How to read findings by risk level?
Most auditors and donors rate findings on three levels: high, medium and low. The exact definitions come from the specific donor’s terms of reference, so check them there first. As a rough guide it looks like this.
| Finding level | Example | What the donor expects in the response |
|---|---|---|
| High (significant deficiency) | One person both approves and executes payments; procurement without comparing quotes; expenses without supporting documents | Immediate action, an owner at director level, a deadline in weeks, evidence of correction (new order, minutes, corrected documents) |
| Medium | Timesheets not signed by a supervisor; project fixed assets without inventory numbers; irregular bank reconciliations | Action plan with a deadline before the next reporting period, a responsible employee, an updated procedure |
| Low | Outdated accounting policy; incomplete details in some acts; no contract register | Agreement or a reasoned explanation, a deadline for correction, no separate evidence at this stage |
Note that minor findings repeated year after year may be raised by the auditor to a significant deficiency. The application material of ISA 265 (paragraphs A17 and A24) expressly allows that failure to act on previously communicated deficiencies, without a rational explanation, may in itself be a significant deficiency.
How to respond to the donor on a management letter?
The management response is written for each finding separately. A table with these columns works best:
- Position: agree, partly agree or disagree.
- Cause: why it happened, in one or two sentences, without excuses.
- Action: what exactly you are changing (order, procedure, document template, segregation of duties).
- Owner: a job title, not just “accounting”.
- Deadline: a specific date your team can actually meet.
- Evidence: what you will show the donor or auditor as proof.
If you disagree with a finding, attach documents the auditor has not seen and ask to discuss it before the final version of the letter. Under ISA 265 the auditor may include management’s responses in the letter and state whether the auditor has verified their implementation (paragraph A28), so it is better to respond at the draft stage.
A response alone does not mean the donor will accept the report: the donor decides under its own rules. If the report has already been returned, see our article what to do when the donor rejects the audit report.
What will the next audit check?
The next auditor will start with the previous management letter and compare your action plan with reality: was the order issued, does the new procedure work on real transactions, were documents corrected. If a significant deficiency has not been remedied, the auditor will repeat it in the new letter (ISA 265, paragraph A17). So keep the evidence of implementation in one folder together with the response.
Common mistakes in responses: vague phrases like “will be taken into account”, a single “by year end” deadline for all findings, promises the team has no capacity to keep, and no evidence at all. Many findings recur year after year; they are listed in our article common mistakes in donor reporting.
FAQ
Is a management letter mandatory after a grant audit?
Under ISA 265 the auditor always communicates significant internal control deficiencies in writing when they are identified. Whether a separate management letter is required as an annex to the report depends on the donor’s terms of reference: many donors require it.
How much time is given for the management response?
ISA 265 sets no single deadline. The donor sets it or it is agreed with the auditor. In practice it is better to respond before the final version of the letter so that the response is included in it.
What happens if a finding is not fixed before the next audit?
The auditor will repeat it in the new letter, and an unremedied deficiency without a rational explanation may itself become a significant deficiency (ISA 265, paragraphs A17 and A24). For the donor this signals weak project management.
How we help
Since 2000, MK Audit has audited donor-funded projects and prepared management letters with specific recommendations. After the audit we help draft the action plan and management response and update policies and document templates. See grant audit, NGO audit, document templates for NGOs and charities and grant audit preparation checklist. The price is set in a commercial proposal once the scope of work is clarified. Contact us via the contacts page.
Prepared by the MK Audit team